Hernández Hernández had a bad night at Camp Nou. Villarreal had a worse one, and they're the ones who should be answering for it. You do not go two goals up inside seven minutes, fail to take a single shot in the entire second half, and then get to point at the man with the whistle.
The case against the referee has real weight. Archivo VAR, the specialist account that grades officiating, gave Alejandro Hernández Hernández 2.5 out of 10 and flagged four controversial incidents. The one Villarreal care about most is the corner awarded before Barcelona's first goal, when Gulácsi apparently never touched the ball. Gerard Martín's 57th-minute goal followed that corner, finishing a Pedri cross. That's a genuine grievance, and the corner was probably wrong.
It explains one goal. It explains nothing about what came next. Four minutes later Fermín López levelled with a left-footed finish from Lamine Yamal's pass, and in the 67th minute Pau Navarro turned the ball into his own net. Villarreal folded on their own, corner or no corner.


And the decision that drew the loudest noise of the night went nowhere. Barcelona's first-half penalty, given after a VAR review for contact by Tani Oluwaseyi on Yamal, was correctly awarded according to the same Archivo VAR account that hammered the referee overall. Yamal hit the post. The biggest call of the match produced zero goals.
Santi Comesaña went after the official anyway. "In the first half, there were seven Barça players protesting to the referee. That affected him," he said, adding: "In the 2nd half, he started showing us cards. He called four straight fouls that are questionable." That's a midfielder describing his own team getting pinned back and chasing the game, and teams that are chasing give away fouls, and get carded for it.
If Hernández Hernández was working for Barcelona, he has a funny way of showing it. After Fermín López was substituted in the 68th minute, he protested a possible penalty from the bench, the fourth official flagged his reaction, and the referee showed him a straight red. He lost his grip on the evening. He was bad, and he hurt both sides about equally.
Individual moments decided this. Navarro had an afternoon from hell: the own goal that put Barcelona ahead, then a second yellow in deep stoppage time for a clumsy challenge on Raphinha. Neither moment has the referee's fingerprints on it.
Villarreal did almost nothing with their lead. Joan García finished the match without making a save, because Villarreal's only two shots on target were their two goals. After that, nothing. That's on Iñigo Pérez, who is now winless in six LaLiga games against Barcelona (one draw, five defeats). His side scored twice and then spent the rest of the match waiting to lose it.
Pedri turned it around. He was named Man of the Match, set up the opener, and ran the midfield for a side that completed 620 passes. Gerard Martín started the fightback and was part of the defence that kept Villarreal without a shot after the break. Fermín López scored the equaliser, then gifted the referee a red card from the bench, which was daft.
Give Hernández Hernández his 2.5. He earned it. The comeback belongs to Pedri, and the collapse belongs to Villarreal and their coach.




