BYU didn't earn Saturday's 31-29 triple-overtime win at Kansas, and anyone calling it resilience is grading a playoff hopeful on a curve the committee shouldn't use. The Cougars got out of Lawrence alive because their defense, LJ Martin and Bear Bachmeier's legs bailed out an offense that spent a half looking lost against a team that walked in at 4-6.
Start with the detail that should bother Provo most: neither team was flagged once. Zero penalties on either side, the whole game. No phantom hold wiped out a drive, no pass interference call handed Kansas anything. There's no officiating controversy to hide behind here. Every stalled BYU drive died because BYU couldn't execute.
And plenty of them stalled. Kansas bottled up Bachmeier for the first half, holding him to 68 total yards before the break. BYU's only first-half points came on Matthias Dunn's career-long 52-yard field goal, and the Cougars trailed 6-3 at halftime. That one's on Aaron Roderick. He's in his sixth season as offensive coordinator and knows exactly what Bachmeier can do. He had no answer for a Kansas team with a losing record.
BYU carried a 16-6 lead into the fourth quarter, built by a defense that picked off Isaiah Marshall twice in the third quarter. Then Kansas scored the next 10 points, capped by Marshall's 24-yard touchdown pass to Cam Pickett on fourth down with four minutes left. A team with playoff ambitions puts away a 4-6 opponent with a 10-point lead and a quarter to play. BYU let Kansas walk all the way back.
Then Dunn, the same kicker who'd hit from 52, missed a 37-yarder wide left as time expired. He'll wear that miss, but he shouldn't wear it alone. An offense that let Kansas hang around all afternoon is why BYU's playoff hopes came down to one kick in the first place.
Meanwhile, the quarterback who looked most dangerous for long stretches wore Kansas colors. Marshall threw two interceptions, but he also completed 20 of 28 passes for 186 yards and two touchdowns, and ran for 90 yards and a score, including the 10-yard run that put Kansas up seven in the first overtime. BYU's defense spent the day chasing him while its own offense idled.
Bachmeier and Martin are why BYU flies home 9-2. Bachmeier answered Marshall's overtime score with a 2-yard touchdown run, one of his two rushing scores, and threw for 173 yards. Martin carried 25 times for 127 yards and kept BYU alive with an 11-yard touchdown run in the second overtime. After Marshall's incompletion in the third overtime, Bachmeier hit Jojo Phillips for the two-point conversion that ended it. Those were winning plays by winning players, plays they had to make because the scheme around them gave them nothing easy.
The case for BYU is real: a road win in overtime against a Kansas team that had beaten the Cougars in all three of their previous meetings, with playoff hopes still alive and one regular-season game left. Survival counts for something, but it doesn't prove BYU can beat good teams, which is exactly what the committee is supposed to measure. Kansas is 4-7 and 2-6 in the Big 12 after Saturday. BYU needed three overtimes and a two-point conversion to get past them.
BYU entered the weekend No. 10 in the committee's rankings and No. 12 in the AP and coaches polls. The committee's next rankings come out Tuesday. If the Cougars hold at No. 10 after this, the committee wasn't watching.
Cincinnati comes to LaVell Edwards Stadium on Nov. 28. That's Roderick's last chance in the regular season to prove Lawrence was a bad afternoon. If his offense plays like that again, BYU deserves to be left out, and the blame belongs on his play sheet.




