Ciryl Gane won this fight. Stop arguing about the judges and start arguing about the referee.
The people screaming robbery over the 48-47 cards are shouting at the wrong target. Gane outpunched Josh Hokit for five rounds at Madison Square Garden on Saturday to retain the undisputed heavyweight title, and three separate live-scoring outlets had him up in real time by the same kind of margins the official scorecards landed on. Walking forward into jabs costs you rounds, and Hokit did plenty of the walking and little of the landing.
The volume tells the story. Gane's 237 significant strikes set a new single-fight UFC heavyweight record, passing the mark Daniel Cormier held, and the pair combined for 383, another heavyweight record. You don't put up numbers like that while losing. It was a grueling, competitive night, and Gane was the better fighter in it. Gane's performance settles the decision. The eye poke is the real issue.
Early in round one, Gane poked Hokit in the left eye. Replay confirmed it. Hokit complained to Marc Goddard. The action wasn't stopped, no point was deducted, and the fight rolled on with Hokit telling anyone who'd listen that his vision was gone. Afterward he posted that he was seeing triple. Whether that cost him the fight is unknowable, which is exactly the problem: an official is supposed to remove that doubt by enforcing the rule in front of him, and Goddard didn't.
That's on the referee, and it's on the officiating culture that keeps letting this fighter skate. This has happened before. Gane's UFC 321 title bout with Tom Aspinall in October 2025 ended in a no-contest after an eye poke, ruled accidental, and Aspinall is still recovering from the injury. Aspinall has since called Gane a 'big cheater.' Gane's interim-title knockout of Alex Pereira drew its own backlash over illegal shots to the back of the head. Three fights in a row, three foul controversies. One is bad luck. Three is a pattern, and the sensible response to a pattern is to officiate the man more carefully.
Instead the opposite keeps happening. Hokit was so sure of what was coming that he trained blindfolded in the build-up, filming himself doing it, practically daring the sport to protect him. It didn't. That should embarrass the UFC more than it apparently does.
None of this means Hokit earned a sympathy decision. He came in undefeated at 10-0, the breakout act of the division, and he backed up almost none of the pre-fight noise once the cage closed. He pressured Gane, kept closing distance on a bigger man, and head-hunted himself out of a performance that might have actually threatened the champion. The toughness is real and it probably buys him another fight down the line. The win was Gane's, fairly.
Jorge Masvidal, who says he dropped $200k on Hokit, aimed his anger in the right direction even if the motive was his wallet: 'And why wasn't nothing done about the f**king eye poke?' That's the question worth asking about UFC 334, and the UFC doesn't want to answer it, because the answer implicates its own officials.
Gane is the heavyweight champion. He was elevated from interim titleholder when Aspinall vacated in September, this was his first defense, and he deserved to walk out with the belt. The decision was clean. The officiating was sloppy, and until the UFC starts enforcing its own rules on this exact fighter, every Gane win drags an asterisk behind it that his output never asked for.




















