Connor Hellebuyck was bad on Saturday night in St. Louis, and it tells you nothing about whether he can handle pressure. If you want to convict him of folding when it matters, the evidence already exists, and none of it was filed in November.
He stopped the first two shots he faced, then the Blues scored on the next four. The Devils pulled him 9:03 into the game, sent out Jake Allen, the former Blues goalie, and St. Louis went on to win 9-6. Four goals on six shots. That line belongs to Hellebuyck and nobody else, and it was his worst game since New Jersey got him from Winnipeg in the October trade.
Look at how they went in
Brandon Carlo opened the scoring at 1:51, beating a screened Hellebuyck from the right point. New Jersey then challenged an early goal for goaltender interference, the call stood after review, and the failed challenge put the Devils on the penalty kill. St. Louis scored 25 seconds later. The Blues led 3-0 by 5:53.
That sequence is on the bench. Burning a challenge on a call that held up, then handing a hot team a power play in the opening minutes of a road game, is a bad decision, and it did more to bury the goalie than any screen did. Hellebuyck didn't make that call. He just had to live with it.
The goal he should be furious about is Philip Broberg's. It came 48 seconds after Jesper Boqvist got the Devils on the board, and it looked covered before it slid through him. That's the soft one. Add the screen and the power play his own bench handed the Blues, and it was one bad night.
The pressure case lives somewhere else
This was a regular-season road game in late November. No series or elimination at stake, just two points. Calling it a pressure moment cheapens the actual pressure moments, and those are where Hellebuyck's record is damning.
Across his career he has a .916 save percentage in 625 regular-season games and a .903 in 58 playoff games. He went 24-34 across seven postseasons in Winnipeg and never got the Jets past the second round after reaching the Conference Final in 2018. St. Louis has seen the spring version up close: Blues fans chanted "We want Connor" when he was pulled in Game 4 of the 2025 playoffs. That's the real evidence against him. Saturday doesn't belong next to it.
The ones saying this is just a November blip aren't wrong about the start he had. Hellebuyck won his first seven games as a Devil and walked into St. Louis 7-1 with a .912 save percentage. Saturday was his second straight loss, but the first was a 3-2 home defeat to Montreal in which he stopped 25 of 28. Two rough starts hardly add up to a slump. As of this game he sits at 7-2 with an .897, and those numbers will move again with his next start.
Who wears this
Hellebuyck wears the four goals. The Devils' bench wears the challenge. New Jersey's front office knowingly bought the goalie with that playoff record, after he requested a trade out of Winnipeg, skipped training camp and was suspended. They acquired him to fix the one thing his career says he can't, and they won't know if it worked until spring.
Laugh at the stat line all you want. Anyone waving one November period around as proof he chokes is making a strong case look stupid.




