The Maple Leafs just finished a six-game homestand without a single point. Not one. They closed it Saturday by getting shut out 1-0 by Edmonton on an Evan Bouchard goal, and the loudest noise coming out of Toronto right now is a demand to fire Jim Hiller. Fire him if it makes you feel something. It won't fix a thing. Hiller is the last guy who built this mess, and the first one everybody wants to throw overboard.
This was the worst homestand in franchise history. Toronto became only the second team in NHL history to finish a homestand of six or more games with zero points, joining the 1970-71 Los Angeles Kings, who went on to miss the playoffs. Utah, Montreal, New Jersey, Colorado, Minnesota and Edmonton all walked into Scotiabank Arena and walked out with two points. The Leafs were outscored 23-9 over the skid. That's a team getting taken apart in its own building, and Saturday's loss was Toronto's first six-game regulation losing streak at home since 1985.
So yes, it's ugly, and the people reaching for Hiller's number have a case they can point to. Twenty-two games into his tenure, Toronto sits at 8-12-2, two wins in its past 10, eight points out of a wild-card spot. When the Leafs fired Mike Babcock in 2019, they did it 23 games in, with him sitting at 9-10-4 and riding a six-game losing streak. Hiller's pace is worse than the one that got a far more decorated coach thrown out of this market, and that firing was considered fast at the time. By the numbers, the trigger is already there.
The mob has the wrong house. Hiller didn't hire himself. John Chayka did, in June, and Chayka went out and got a coach who had been fired by the Kings that same March, in the middle of a losing stretch there. The GM called Craig Berube the wrong "organizational shift," then replaced him with a man another franchise had cut loose months earlier. If Hiller is in over his head, the person who looked at his résumé and signed off is sitting one office up, and he hasn't said a word while his hire takes every arrow.
Chayka answers to a building that's on a genuine losing run across sports. Rogers now owns all of MLSE, and Keith Pelley runs both MLSE and Rogers Media at the same time. In the same calendar year, this ownership group has watched the Blue Jays go from the World Series to a 79-83 last-place finish in the AL East, out of the playoffs by September. Now the hockey team is making history nobody wanted. It's a pattern set by the people at the top, and firing the newest employee is the cheapest way to pretend otherwise.
Hiller's own read on the homestand was that his group deserved better. "Guys played their tail off; I don't think anyone's going to question that," he said. "I'd like to see them get rewarded, but I'm going to tell you, we deserved better than that from the six-game homestand. And we didn't, so we'll move on to the next one." You can roll your eyes at a coach praising a team that lost six straight at home. But a coach can't score the goals, and a $50-million core that includes Matthews, Nylander and Tavares getting shut out at home by Edmonton is a talent-and-leadership failure the coach inherited.
The schedule eases immediately, with Chicago, Los Angeles and Columbus on deck. That's the organization's built-in excuse to wait. Waiting makes sense anyway, because firing Hiller now would be an admission that the men who assembled this roster would rather burn the coach than look in a mirror. Sixty games remain. Nothing about 22 games is a death sentence for a season.
Sack Hiller and you'll still have the same roster and the same GM who bet on a just-fired coach, under ownership that's now steered two flagship teams into the ditch in one year. The coach is the symptom. The disease has a corner office, and nobody in it is volunteering to pay for this.




