Xabi Alonso is out of his depth at the top level, and a like on Instagram doesn't change that. If Vinícius Jr. really did tap the heart on a post about Chelsea getting thumped 4-1 at home by Leeds, it was petty, and Alonso earned it.
⚡ Upset:Leeds had a 26% chance before kickoff and beat Chelsea 4–1.
Start with the like, since it's the smallest part of this story. A like attributed to Vinícius showed up on a post about the defeat and went viral, spread from a screenshot off a fan account, and nothing more solid has confirmed it since. Plenty of people will say a like is just a like and the whole thing is overblown. They're right about that part. What they're missing is that nobody would care about a thumb on a screen if the scoreline underneath it weren't so ugly.


The scoreline is the problem
Leeds beat Chelsea 4-1 at Stamford Bridge on November 21, with Noah Okafor scoring twice. It was Leeds' first Premier League win at the Bridge in 27 years, and Chelsea's own fans booed them off the pitch. That was Chelsea's fifth league defeat of the season and their third in four games. It left them 8th on 16 points, with Leeds above them in 6th.
Alonso's own read afterwards: "We are disappointed. We are sad. It was tough today with the defeat. We probably are in a fragile moment after our good start."
Fragile is a generous word for it. He has flipped between three and four at the back and hasn't used the same defensive line and goalkeeper combination in consecutive league games. In pre-season he was rolling out the back three that won him everything at Leverkusen. Now Chelsea supporters can't tell what system they're watching, and judging by the team sheets, neither can he. Less than five months into a four-year contract, a manager should know his best back line. Alonso doesn't.
Madrid was the warning
The Vinícius feud belongs to Real Madrid, and it's over: Alonso was appointed there in June 2025 and his spell ended seven months later. Alonso doesn't manage Vinícius anymore. But how that relationship fell apart explains a lot about what's happening in west London.
Alonso benched Vinícius against Oviedo, and Vinícius came off the bench to score late in a 3-0 win. He benched him again for the Champions League game against Marseille and started Rodrygo. Then in October's 2-1 Clásico win he hooked Vinícius in the 72nd minute, and the winger stormed down the tunnel. Vinícius apologised to his teammates and the club president afterwards. He left Alonso out.
Jamie Carragher's version: "If we're really being honest, Xabi Alonso lost his job because of Vinícius Jr." Carragher has it backwards. Alonso stuck Vinícius on the right wing for a Club World Cup semifinal that Madrid lost 5-2 to PSG, then spent months trying to prove a point to his best forward instead of getting the best out of him. That was a manager's decision, and it failed. The tantrum in the tunnel was ugly, and Vinícius owned it to everyone in the building except Alonso. He never apologized to the one man he actually blamed.
The Leverkusen double in 2023/24, unbeaten in the league, was brilliant, and nobody can take it away from him. Since then he has gone through a Madrid job that lasted seven months and a Chelsea team that got booed off its own pitch by November. One perfect season and two big clubs he couldn't settle is a pattern now.
Chelsea deserve some of this too. Alonso is their sixth permanent manager in four years, after Tuchel, Potter, Pochettino, Maresca and Rosenior, and they handed him four years on the strength of one season in Germany. They bought the reputation without asking why it broke at Madrid.
So yes, the like is childish. Vinícius should let it go and worry about his own football. But a petty like doesn't lose 4-1 to Leeds. Alonso does. He looked like a manager who'd lost the dressing room at Madrid, and he looks like one who can't pick a back four at Chelsea. Vinícius saw what he was before anyone in west London did.




