Arsenal are not hard done by. Pro Ref has now admitted to three penalty-related mistakes against them this season, Arsenal won all three of those games, and the one officiating error that might actually have decided a result went in their favour at Anfield.
Pro Ref is bad at its job. What's falling apart is the Arsenal victim story built on top of it.
The Hull ruling
This week the Key Match Incidents Panel voted 5-0 that Havertz should have had a penalty in the 1-0 win over Hull on November 7. In the 42nd minute Nobel Mendy pulled him back in the box. Referee Farai Hallam and VAR let it go because Havertz was offside. The panel's explanation was blunt: "there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz."
The foul came first. The offside came second. Working out which happened first is the entire job of the VAR room, and the people paid to do it got it backwards. That's a disgrace, and the officials own it completely. Arsenal still won.
The ledger
Go through the three mistakes that went against Arsenal and look at what each one cost.
- Aston Villa, Matchweek 2. The panel ruled unanimously that Arsenal should have had a penalty for Ian Maatsen's late challenge on Bruno Guimaraes, and that Maatsen, already booked, should have gone off for a second yellow. Arsenal won 1-0.
- Sunderland, September 12. John Brooks penalised Ezri Konsa for holding Dan Ballard at a corner. The panel said unanimously that the penalty was wrong. David Raya saved Enzo Le Fee's kick and Arsenal won 2-0. Mikel Arteta called it "unacceptable" and "impossible."
- Hull, November 7. Won 1-0.
Three wins, nine points from nine. You can't be robbed of points you took home.
Now Anfield, November 1. In the 21st minute, with Arsenal ahead through Havertz, Jurrien Timber grabbed Alexander Isak's shirt as a cross came in. Andy Madley waved play on, and Stuart Attwell in the VAR chair backed him. The panel voted 4-1 that it should have been a penalty and 3-2 that VAR should have sent Madley to the monitor. Havertz's goal was the only one of the game. Liverpool's manager put it simply: "There is a clear grab of the shirt."
Of all the botched calls in Arsenal games this season, that's the only one that landed while the wronged side was a goal down in a game that ended by that same single goal. Liverpool are the club with a real grievance here. Arsenal just have a list of irritations.
The pattern argument
One count has the panel overturning officials in five of Arsenal's first ten league games, four of them against Arsenal. That's a real run, and it points to something wrong right now.
That something is Pro Ref. Holding in the box, fouls tangled up with offsides, the same blind spots again and again. Attwell sat in the VAR chair for both Sunderland and Anfield. On the Sunderland call, the panel decided Brooks was wrong but voted 3-2 that Attwell was right not to step in, which means the man with every replay angle got cleared for leaving a wrong penalty in place. That verdict is absurd, and it comes from the body supposed to be holding officials to account.
So yes, Arsenal keep getting caught in the crossfire of an incompetent system. Feeling hard done by requires losing something, though, and Arsenal haven't. As of November 18, they sit top of the table on 27 points from ten games, five clear of Brighton. A club in that position, with Arteta raging about Sunderland penalties his own goalkeeper saved, is asking for sympathy it hasn't earned.
Aim the fury at Pro Ref's VAR room, which keeps blowing the same calls under a different name. Save the sympathy for the clubs who actually walked off the pitch with less than they deserved. Arsenal isn't one of them this season.




