Four 6-4 SEC teams in the College Football Playoff Top 25 is an embarrassment, and the selection committee did it to itself. On Tuesday night it found room for South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida and Ole Miss, four losses apiece, and no room at all for a 9-1 Liberty team the AP voters have at No. 22.
No 6-4 team had ever been ranked in the committee's Top 25 before the November 17 reveal. Then four arrived at once, at No. 21, No. 22, No. 24 and No. 25, with 7-3 Louisville wedged between them at No. 23. All four are from the SEC.
A fourth loss is free in the right conference
Look at Ole Miss. The Rebels lost last weekend and stayed in at No. 25. Losing is supposed to cost you something in a ranking. For Ole Miss it cost nothing, because the committee had already decided that an SEC team with four losses outranks almost anybody with fewer.
As of this week's reveal, the SEC has nine teams in the Top 25, more than any other conference, with the Big Ten next at six. Some of those nine earned it. Georgia is 9-1 and No. 1. Texas is 8-2 and jumped Notre Dame for No. 5 after winning at LSU. The fight is at the bottom, where the committee stacked four .600 teams and waved strength of schedule over them.
Who else? Teams that won.
The committee's defenders have one real argument. Duke and SMU, both 7-3, are the only Power Four teams with fewer than four losses sitting outside the rankings, and both carry losses you'd want to hide. Duke lost 28-25 to Georgia Tech in October and lost by double digits to Miami. SMU has dropped two of its last three and trailed Wake Forest 42-0 at halftime. Beyond those two, the only other Power Four teams getting AP votes are four-loss SEC teams: LSU, Auburn and Missouri.
The alternative is Liberty. The Flames are 9-1. Their only loss came on the road at James Madison, 20-13, in Week 1, and they haven't lost since. New Mexico is 8-2 and AP-ranked too. The Lobos lost 21-17 to UNLV and 14-6 at Oklahoma in September. Oklahoma beat them head-to-head, which justifies ranking the Sooners above New Mexico. It doesn't justify leaving New Mexico off the list entirely while Florida and Ole Miss stay on it.
The "who else" question only looks unanswerable if you've already decided the answer has to come from a Power Four conference. The committee decided that. It looked at teams that keep winning, then ranked teams that keep losing, because the losing teams play in the SEC.
Arkansas coach Bret Bielema answered the rankings with clown emojis. He was being generous.
The committee is miscalibrated everywhere
The other pushback is that this committee has been off all season, so the 6-4 picks are just one more symptom. Unbeaten Utah sits at No. 2 behind 9-1 Georgia. Unbeaten UCLA sits at No. 4 behind 8-2 Alabama. Agreed, and it makes the 6-4 picks worse. A committee that can't sort out its own top four has no business telling you a four-loss Florida belongs ahead of a one-loss Liberty.
Now picture 24 teams
In a 12-team field, the committee's No. 21 through No. 25 are mostly bragging rights. Expand the bracket to 24 and this exact stretch of the poll becomes the bubble. The committee just showed you how it fills the bubble: with SEC teams that lost four times, ahead of teams that won nine.
This list will move. Two weeks of regular season, conference championship weekend and one more reveal remain, and the four 6-4 teams can still win their way into looking respectable. What the committee told everybody on November 17 doesn't move. It ranks teams by the conference they lose in, and giving that committee 24 bracket spots would be malpractice.




