Yes. The 24-team playoff is gutting the thing that made college football worth watching, and Tony Petitti's name belongs on it. The Big Ten commissioner drove this format, told the SEC the field would either go to 24 or stay at 12, and got exactly what he wanted.
Look at the committee's third rankings of the season, released Nov. 17. Georgia, Utah, Alabama and UCLA sit in the top four, Texas jumped into the top five, and as of that release Alabama, Texas, Tennessee and BYU were all in the top ten at 8-2. There are still two more rankings to come before the 12-team field for this season is set, and every one of those two-loss teams knows one more bad Saturday could leave them watching from home. That fear is why November in this sport feels like an elimination game every single week.
Now run the same list through the format that starts in 2027. Twenty-four teams: 19 at-large bids, automatic spots for the four Power 4 conference champions and the highest-ranked Group of Six team. The top eight seeds get a first-round bye, and the first two rounds, 16 games in all, are played on the higher seed's campus. Under that setup, those 8-2 teams are just haggling over seeding. A 7-5 team will still be in the running for a spot. A November loss is now just a line item.
The man who did it
One man pushed this through. The Big Ten and SEC hold authority over the playoff's format, and only one of them wanted this. Greg Sankey favored a 12- or 16-team field that would have kept the SEC championship game, and he said repeatedly that he preferred incremental expansion to 16. Petitti had already brought the ACC, the Big 12 and Notre Dame on board, then drew his line: 24, or the field stays at 12. Sankey signed off anyway.
So Sankey wears some of this. He had the leverage of co-ownership and he blinked. The format is Petitti's, though. He built it and forced it through, and he owns every meaningless late-season game it produces.
What they sold it for
ESPN signed a five-year deal worth nearly $1.7 billion to stay the playoff's sole broadcast partner through the expansion. ESPN chairman Jimmy Pitaro says the network is "firmly committed to elevating it in its new, expanded 24-team format." Of course he is.
The real number is smaller and uglier. ESPN's added payment averages $345 million a year on top of the roughly $1.3 billion it already pays annually, but about $140 million of that comes back to the network because the SEC, Big 12 and ACC championship games it held rights to will no longer be played. ESPN's actual net increase lands near $205 million a year. That's the price. Four conference title games erased, a regular season hollowed out, for about $205 million a year in new money. The people running this sport sold its best feature cheap.
The access argument
The best case for this thing goes like this: more teams in means smaller programs finally get a real shot, and December fills up with games that matter. Petitti's side and a few columnists have also argued that byes and home games keep the regular season tense.
Start with December. This deal deletes the Power 4 conference championship games, which were some of the most meaningful December games the sport had. You can't claim you're adding stakes to the month while bulldozing its biggest weekend.
Then the underdogs. Northwestern's 1995 team won the Big Ten and reached the Rose Bowl for the first time in 47 years, losing 41-32 to USC. That season still gets retrospectives decades later because it was so hard to pull off. Make the door wide enough and that run is just seed 21.
As for byes: a top-eight seed and a home game are worth chasing. That chase is also exactly what the NFL's December looks like, and the reason people fell for college football is that its regular season never looked like the NFL's.
Petitti held the sport's best feature hostage, Sankey paid the ransom, and ESPN wrote the check. Remember all three names the first time a 7-5 team's season is still alive in December.




