CIES has published a list of the hundred most valuable goalkeepers in the world, and the model behind it can't see a save. Every figure on it is a price tag on age, contract length and club badge. Putting the word "goalkeepers" at the top of that list is misleading, and CIES owns that.
The CIES Football Observatory's 562nd Weekly Post landed on Wednesday, November 18. The top of it reads like this: Barcelona's Joan García first at €80.6 million, Manchester City's Gianluigi Donnarumma second at €79.9 million, Manchester United's Senne Lammens third at €64.2 million and Aston Villa's Zion Suzuki fourth at €59.5 million. Then come Bart Verbruggen (Brighton), Mike Penders (Chelsea), Lukáš Hornicek (Newcastle), Robin Roefs (Sunderland), Matvey Safonov (PSG) and Jonas Urbig (Bayern Munich), who rounds out the ten at €50.0 million. Seven of the ten play for Premier League clubs.
What the model actually reads
Look at what goes into those numbers. The published CIES framework has no goalkeeper-specific measures in it, shot-stopping included. It knows a keeper's age, his contract, his club, his league and how much he plays. CIES's own commentary on this list says age and contract duration weigh the most. So when García tops the list at 25, on a Barcelona deal that runs to 2031, the model is rewarding his birth certificate and his paperwork. Whether he can stop a shot never enters the sum.
Verbruggen is the giveaway: he sits fifth at €57.9 million. In 2024-25 he was level with Arijanet Muric for the most errors leading to goals among Premier League goalkeepers, five apiece. In 2025-26 he led the league outright with four. Any scout who watched those seasons would laugh at the idea of him as the fifth most valuable keeper on the planet. The model put him there because everything it reads about him points up, and the mistakes are invisible to it.
Belgium's awkward question
Belgium has turned this into a national story, and it's also the best evidence of how blind the model is. Lammens is third, Penders sixth, Maarten Vandevoordt around 24th at about €37 million. Thibaut Courtois, Belgium's most decorated goalkeeper, ranks behind his younger compatriots. I'd take Courtois over every keeper above him for one match that matters, and so would anyone who has watched him play.
Penders shows how jumpy these outputs are. In April, a separate CIES under-23 ranking had him at €47 million. Seven months later this list has him at €57.1 million. The model doesn't count saves, so something else pushed that number up.
And David Raya, who is 31, doesn't make the top ten. The people who built the model say age weighs the most, and that's why he's off it.
The market already tested it
The best defence of these figures is that they track what clubs would pay, and clubs really do pay for youth and long contracts. Put Courtois on the market tomorrow and somebody would still write a big cheque. Fine. Then check the one keeper on this list whose price the market actually set. When Manchester City signed Donnarumma from PSG, the fee was put at around £26 million in British accounts and closer to €35 million in others. CIES now values him at €79.9 million. Take the higher fee and City still paid less than half the model's number. The one time a real club had to buy Donnarumma, the price looked nothing like this.
The outlets from Portugal to Brazil to Belgium running this as a who's-best chart are making it worse, with Belgian papers openly asking why Courtois sits so low. CIES built the thing, put "goalkeepers" in the headline and sent it out to be read exactly that way. If the model only prices age, contract and club, call it a contract-and-age index and leave the position out of it.
A research centre that can't measure the one thing a goalkeeper is paid to do has no business ranking a hundred of them.




