Curt Cignetti lost this game, and the run of close calls that people now want to file under bad luck is the best evidence against him. His staff knew for months that the kicking was broken and that the quarterback job was unsettled. In Seattle both problems showed up in the same overtime, with a reigning national champion's season riding on them.
Indiana has been to overtime three times in four weeks, and a team that keeps playing coin-flip games will eventually lose one. Fair enough. But the Hoosiers kept ending up in those games for a specific reason: through 11 games they had missed 10 field goals and two extra points. A team that leaves points on the field week after week ends up in tight finishes it had no business being in. Those overtime escapes were warnings, and the coach who heard them was Cignetti.
He more or less admitted it afterward. "We've missed too many field goals this year," Cignetti said. He's right, and that's exactly the problem. Nico Radicic had missed six of his last 12 kicks over the previous five games, and the coach's response was a short leash he described himself: "That was the plan going in." Radicic's 46-yard attempt was blocked in the third quarter, and Paddy McAteer took over the job.
Now look at what actually beat Indiana. Washington offensive lineman Drew Azzopardi got a hand on Radicic's kick. In overtime, the same Azzopardi got a hand on McAteer's 37-yarder and sent it wide, and Husky Stadium emptied onto the field. McAteer is the kicker who drilled a 60-yard game-winner against Minnesota and hit a 34-yarder earlier in this very game to put Indiana ahead 17-14. His leg was fine. Cignetti changed the man kicking the ball and left alone the protection that let one Washington player reach two kicks in a single game. Once a block happens in the third quarter, the staff has the rest of regulation to fix the wall in front of the kicker. By overtime they hadn't, and that failure belongs to the coaches.
Then there's the quarterback. Tied 14-14 with 9:59 left in the third quarter, Cignetti pulled Grant Wilson and sent Josh Hoover back in, his second quarterback switch in three games. Hoover had been the starter for most of the season, got benched for Wilson during the Minnesota game, watched Wilson finish a 23-16 win and then start the 27-13 win over No. 14 USC, and was back in Saturday because the offense had stalled. Cignetti's explanation: "I went in fully hoping and believing Grant would do well and make it through the whole game."
Hoping and believing. That's how a fan talks about his team's quarterback. A coach defending a national title is supposed to know who his quarterback is by the 11th game, and Cignetti was still working it out in the third quarter in Seattle. Two mid-game hooks in three weeks means neither player can take a snap without wondering if it's his last one.
The cost is already on the board. As of Sunday, Nov. 22, Indiana is 9-2 and tied for second in the Big Ten with Oregon and Iowa, with Purdue left on the schedule. Pro Football Network's model put the Hoosiers' playoff chances at 33.9% at that point, with 32.5 points of it coming from winning the Big Ten and just 1.4% from an at-large spot. The safety net is gone. Indiana now has to win its way in through the conference, with the same kicking unit and the same quarterback question it carried into this week.
Luck covered for Curt Cignetti's decisions for a month. On Saturday it ran out, and this loss is his.




