Lane Kiffin's first season at LSU is the biggest disappointment in college football, and the blame sits with exactly one man. Plenty of programs are miserable this fall. Only one of them is run by a coach who walked out on an 11-1 playoff team to go get his.
He chose this
Remember how this started. Kiffin announced he was leaving Ole Miss exactly one week before the 12-team College Football Playoff bracket was set, with the Rebels all but certain to be in. Ole Miss refused to let him coach them through the playoff, handed the job to Pete Golding, and Golding took that team to the semifinals.
Kiffin went to Baton Rouge for the resources. By one count, LSU's roster is valued at more than $50 million and was built on the nation's best transfer portal class. Through 11 games, that roster is 6-5 and 3-5 in the SEC after a 27-13 loss to Tennessee. That's more losses in one season than Brian Kelly had in any of his four years in the SEC. LSU lost to Texas 22-21. It keeps finding ways to lose close ones.
The Tennessee game was an indictment of the coaching staff. LSU turned it over three times, including a critical Sam Leavitt fumble, and has turned it over eight times across its last three games. It committed 16 penalties, the most the program has committed in a single game in more than 30 years. A team with that much talent doesn't rack up that many penalties unless the man in charge has lost control of the details.
The quarterback is his too
Leavitt, the Arizona State transfer, has taken a beating this year, and he's earned some of it. Nick Saban said: "What's LSU's issue? To me, turning the ball over and the quarterback's been responsible for that to a large degree." But Leavitt is Kiffin's quarterback, playing in Kiffin's offense behind Kiffin's portal line. You don't get to buy the roster and then disown what it does on Saturdays.
Asked about the roster, Kiffin said: "We'll have better rosters, and that's no poor reflection upon these players." Then: "We won't have Senior Days with 2 scholarship players." Talking about next year's roster in the middle of a lost season, after LSU spent like this, is a coach shopping for an alibi. He knows how it reads. He said it anyway.
The year-one argument
It's one season. "Era" is a big word for 11 games. Other programs are faceplanting just as hard. Ohio State has its most losses in a season since 2011 and an interim coach after losing to Nebraska. Texas A&M is already out of bowl eligibility. Michigan was 5-5 in Kyle Whittingham's first year as of last week, while the Utah team he left sits No. 2 in the CFP rankings.
Those are ugly. None of them match this. Ohio State and Texas A&M are living with decisions that went wrong over time. Whittingham left a Utah team headed for the Las Vegas Bowl, which is a long way from the bracket. Kiffin left a team a week away from the playoff. He took the biggest portal haul in the country with him into the job, and he still has a 6-5 team that commits 16 penalties in a game. Call it premature to judge the whole era if you like. This season is already in the books as a disaster, with only a bowl left to play for.
The glee across the SEC is earned. Lane Kiffin traded a semifinal run for this, and every one of those five losses is his.




