Keith Pelley looked at a team that hadn't won a game in November and decided what it needed was a golfer. The Toronto Maple Leafs have a roster problem and a coaching problem, and the man running the company keeps treating both like a mood.
Toronto lost 4-3 in a shootout to the Kings at Scotiabank Arena on Thursday night, its eighth straight game without a win (0-7-1 over that run). Rory McIlroy read the starting lineup to the players in the locker room before that game. On Friday morning, the Leafs canceled practice and spent two hours with McIlroy and his sports psychologist, Bob Rotella, in a session Pelley, the president and CEO of MLSE, ran himself. Through Thursday, Toronto sat at 8-13-3 and last in the Atlantic Division. Its last win came on Oct. 31, a 4-2 result against Vancouver.
The coach already told you what's missing
Jim Hiller laid out why Gavin McKenna, the 18-year-old first overall pick, hasn't gotten more high-leverage ice time: "We haven't had a lot of practice time this year in getting preparation for the season. It's a short season. But we're going to do that."
The coach says this team is short on practice. So with the season sliding, the franchise took a practice day and gave it to a golf talk. Hiller then called it "probably the most impactful thing we could get out of the day." Of course he did. A coach with his job in question isn't going to tell reporters the CEO's guest burned his morning. He also says he isn't thinking about job security. Everybody else in Toronto is.
Rotella is a renowned sports psychologist, and plenty of teams bring in mental-skills people when things go sideways. Nobody should sneer at that idea. What sinks this one is the room it happened in. You don't get honesty out of players when the CEO is the one running the conversation. Nobody's going to stand up and say the system is broken, or the lineup makes no sense, with the boss facilitating. And a golfer, whose sport has no linemates and no coach parceling out his minutes, is the wrong voice for what's going wrong in Toronto.
Preplanned makes it worse
The session was preplanned, and the McIlroy connection is real. Pelley ran the DP World Tour before he took over MLSE, and after the two played the RBC Canadian Open pro-am in June 2025, he gave McIlroy a Leafs sweater. McIlroy, who had just finished the career Grand Slam at Augusta that April, joked, "If I can win the Masters, then the Leafs can win the Stanley Cup."
So the visit was coming either way. Canceling Friday's practice to fit it in came after the eighth loss. Somebody looked at that skid and decided a celebrity sit-down was worth more than a day on the ice. That's a hockey call, and it was the wrong one.
The real problem can't be talked away
On Monday, GM John Chayka gave Hiller a vote of confidence at practice. Toronto then lost to Chicago and Los Angeles. The Leafs don't own their first-round picks in 2027 or 2028; both went out on the same day in March 2025, in separate deals with Boston and Philadelphia. McKenna is in Toronto because the lottery balls bounced their way.
That's a team with almost no easy way to add talent and a coach being second-guessed over how he uses the one prize it has. Rotella can't trade for a player, and McIlroy can't move McKenna up the depth chart. Nothing said in that room on Friday changes who dresses or what Chayka has to bargain with.
When Pelley arrived in May 2024, he said, "We're not here to sell jerseys. We're here to win." Friday was a famous name in the dressing room during an eight-game skid, with the CEO at the front of the room. That's the jersey business.
The streak is still alive, and Hiller's future is still unresolved. The Leafs are approaching 60 years without a Stanley Cup, and Keith Pelley owns this mess. On Friday he proved he still thinks it's in the players' heads.




