Jim Hiller should lose his job, and John Chayka should have to explain why he gave it to him in the first place. Through Thursday's games, the Maple Leafs were 8-13-3, winless in eight straight (0-7-1), and had lost 10 of their last 11.
Hiller delivered the verdict himself after the fourth loss in a row, against Colorado earlier this month: "We've played a lot of good hockey this year, but our results suck... Our record is what it is, and it's deserved."
He's right about the second half. Take him at his word.
The report rests on one writer
As of Friday, the firing talk traces back to one person. Howard Berger, a longtime independent Toronto hockey writer, posted that Hiller will likely be replaced after Saturday night's game against Columbus, and that he's hearing Bruce Boudreau's name as an interim, "but I'm not sure." No other outlet had independently confirmed it by Friday morning. Everyone repeating it was repeating him.
Berger's defenders say his sources still deliver. His big Leafs call from this summer doesn't help them: in June he posted that Morgan Rielly would go to San Jose for a middle-round pick. Rielly was still a Leaf when this season began, and the Sharks chose Darnell Nurse instead. Treat the Saturday timeline and the Boudreau name as rumor until somebody else stands behind them.
None of that saves Hiller. The argument for firing him never needed a tweet.
What he's presided over
Toronto just went 0-6-0 on a homestand, outscored 23-9, every loss in regulation. The Leafs became only the second team in NHL history to finish a homestand of six games or longer without a point, and it was their first six-game regulation losing streak at home since 1985. Over the eight-game skid they were outscored 33-15. Somewhere in there they couldn't beat the Kings, the team that fired Hiller last season.
Nobody talks his way out of a month like that. It ends coaching tenures, and it should end his.
This is Chayka's mess
Chayka knew Hiller's history when he hired him. The Kings fired Hiller on March 1, 2026, after a 24-21-14 record that included a 2-5-1 finish over his last eight games. Chayka, who had fired Craig Berube in May citing the need for an "organizational shift," then spoke with 25 candidates in a search he called "a long process... an exhaustive process," and on June 17 hired the coach LA had just let go. The selling point was familiarity: Hiller was a Leafs assistant from 2015 to 2019 under Mike Babcock.
A coach with a fresh mid-season collapse on his record, brought home because people in the building knew him, was the organizational shift Chayka promised. Toronto is now living through a worse slide than the one that cost him the Kings job.
The best reason to keep him is how bad firing him looks. Chayka has said he and Mats Sundin remain fully behind Hiller. A second coaching change inside a year looks chaotic, and the Leafs would be paying two coaches. Berger's reply when the money came up: "MLSE is worth only $4 billion. I assume they can handle it.." He's not wrong. As for the chaos, it already happened, back in June, when Chayka picked this guy. Keeping a failing coach so the general manager doesn't have to admit a mistake is the worst reason to do anything in pro sports.
And if the roster is the bigger problem, check who built it. Same desk.
Boudreau, and the Columbus problem
If Chayka has already made the call, making Hiller run Saturday's bench first is pointless and a little cruel. Hand it to an assistant and get on with it.
Boudreau would be fine as an interim. He hasn't coached in the NHL since the Canucks let him go in January 2023, and Berger himself wasn't sure about the name, but an interim's job is to stop the bleeding and let the room breathe for a few weeks. A veteran who's been around the league can do that. What Chayka can't do is treat a caretaker as a solution and buy himself another half-season of cover.
Hiller should pay for this season with his job. Chayka already spent his first big hire on a coach LA had thrown back, and he's earned zero benefit of the doubt on the next one.




