Jim Hiller should be fired. Toronto shouldn't spend the rest of November auditioning him first. A team that coughs up a 3-1 lead at home in the final five minutes, two days after blowing a 3-0 lead to the Kings, has a coaching problem, and the coach is the one in the chair right now.
That chair belongs to Hiller. Craig Berube was fired on May 13, 2026, and general manager John Chayka hired Hiller in June to replace him. Every game of this slide has been Hiller's.
Fifty-two seconds
Saturday's 4-3 loss to Columbus pushed Toronto's winless run to nine games (0-8-1). The Leafs have dropped 11 of their last 12. You have to go back to the 1985-86 team, which lost nine straight from Oct. 16 to Nov. 6, 1985, to find a slide this long.
Look at how this one ended. William Nylander coughed up the puck in his own zone, Matthew Knies scored the tying goal against his former club, and on the very next faceoff Zach Werenski walked in uncontested and beat Anthony Stolarz with 3:28 left. The whole collapse took 52 seconds, off a faceoff, right after a goal against. Somebody chose who was on the ice for that draw and how they'd defend it, and that somebody is paid to get exactly that moment right. Protecting a lead late is the most basic job a bench boss has, and this bench has now failed at it twice in three days.
Columbus dominated the game too, controlling 66 percent of expected goals. After the game, Auston Matthews called the loss "inexcusable" and admitted he had no answer for why the team keeps surrendering leads, pointing to a forecheck that disappeared and too little time spent in the offensive zone. When your captain can't explain the third period, the man who designs the third period has run out of excuses.
The Marchenko defence
Kirill Marchenko came over from Columbus on the eve of the season and had six goals and 14 points in 14 games before a lower-body injury knocked him out on Oct. 26. Toronto is 1-8-1 without him this season. Lose your best scoring winger and the goals dry up.
Except the goals didn't dry up on Saturday. Matthews, Jake McCabe and Teddy Blueger scored, Stolarz made 31 saves, and Toronto had the two-goal cushion it needed. Then it gave all of it back.
Marchenko's injury doesn't explain Hiller's collapses in the third period. Even with him healthy for almost all of October, the Leafs finished that month eighth in the East. He makes this team better. The third-period collapses sit with the coaching staff.
That injury does land on someone, and it's Chayka. He built a roster so thin on the wings that one man's absence drops it from mediocre to 8-13-3 entering Saturday, dead last in the Atlantic and 14th in the East. He's also the one who looked at a coach the Kings had fired in March 2026 and decided that was the fix for what Berube couldn't solve. Firing Hiller still leaves Chayka next in line to answer for it.
Four games left in November
The Leafs still have four November games: at the Islanders on Nov. 23, at Boston on Nov. 27, at Pittsburgh on Nov. 28 and home to Philadelphia on Nov. 30. Waiting to see whether Hiller can scrape a couple of wins out of that stretch is how management buys itself another month of cover.
This loss came against a Columbus team that sat seventh in the Metropolitan Division with 18 points through 21 games. Losing like that to a team like that, with a two-goal lead and five minutes to play, is the coach's failure. Fire Hiller now, and then Chayka can stand in front of the people paying for seats at Scotiabank Arena and explain why he hired him.




