Blow it up, all of it. Kyle Dubas finally said trades are coming, and the only thing worse than another season of patching around Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin would be a "future-oriented" sell-off that still saves a winger for Crosby's comfort.
As of November 18, Pittsburgh is 7-11-2 through 20 games, 15th in the Eastern Conference, ahead of only Columbus, with six losses in its last eight. That's the roster Dubas chose to keep together. He signed Andrei Kuzmenko, kept Bryan Rust and Rickard Rakell, and held on to Erik Karlsson. Now, at a rare in-season availability, he's telling everyone: "At this time, I don't think it's prudent for the Pittsburgh Penguins to give up future draft picks or prospects to add more veterans to our group."
Correct, but late.
Listen to the hedge buried in his next answer: "If we carry on in this way, I think the types of transactions you'll see from us will be very future-oriented." Twenty games in, with only Columbus below them in the East, there's no "if" left. Dubas also said the playoffs won't decide how he grades this season, and he asked the right question: "When we get to the end of the year, are we a step further to actually being in contention?" Answer it by selling.
Stop saving a winger for Crosby
Josh Yohe expects at least one of Rust and Rakell to be moved by the March 1 deadline, and believes Dubas will keep the other so Crosby has a winger to play with. That's the move I'd fight hardest. Rust is 34, Rakell is 33, and both are signed through next season. Keeping one of them is a sentimental half-step, the exact kind of decision that left this team stuck. If the return is real, sell both.
Dubas told everyone himself what he wants: more players in their 20s, like Egor Chinakhov and Elmer Soderblom. Those players need the ice time. A veteran winger kept around as a security blanket on a team chasing Columbus in the standings does nothing for the contender Dubas claims to be building.
Sell Karlsson while the number looks good
Karlsson is the hardest sell and the most obvious one. He's 36 with a full no-movement clause, Dubas has been listening on him and Kris Letang for weeks, and Yohe believes Karlsson would accept a trade to a real Cup contender. Karlsson isn't pretending otherwise: "I think all the speculations are pretty given," he said. "There's nothing strange about that."
Through 20 games he has 19 points, the most on the team. A rebuilding GM should love that line, because it's the first thing a buyer reads. The rest of his game has been ugly. He's been on the ice for 24 five-on-five goals against in those 20 games, and in the loss to Boston his own-zone turnover handed Elias Lindholm a breakaway goal on a minus-4 night. Cash in the points before every other front office finishes watching the tape.
Wanting Malkin and Letang to finish their careers in Pittsburgh is understandable. It shouldn't stop a single phone call.
Crosby is Crosby's call
The strongest case for Dubas moving slower is Crosby himself. He still drives games, he scored twice in the win over the Kings earlier this month, and tearing everything down around a player that good feels wasteful. But the answer is already on the record. Yohe's reporting is blunt: "The truth is, everything is in his hands. If Crosby wants to keep playing with the Penguins after this season, they will naturally accommodate his wishes. If he wants to be traded, Dubas will trade him."
So let Crosby decide Crosby. Dubas has met with the veterans as a group, talks regularly with Crosby's agent, Pat Brisson, and calls the situation "as unique as it gets," adding, "He's owed all the respect in the world." That's fair. That respect doesn't require building the whole roster around his wing.
And look at who else is on the clock. Crosby, Malkin, Karlsson, Kuzmenko, Samuel Girard, Spencer Stastney and Justin Brazeau are all pending unrestricted free agents after this season. Patching around that list means trading assets to support players whose deals are running out. Incremental moves from a 15th-place team buy you a slightly less bad 15th-place team and a thinner prospect cupboard.
This losing roster is on Dubas now, and he only earns back patience by selling every veteran he's allowed to sell, starting now.




