Montreal won 3-2 in Newark on Wednesday, but for 60 minutes they didn't play like a playoff team. They played like a team that had lost two straight and refused to lose a third, which is a less flattering way to get the same two points.
The box score reads clean. Alex Newhook answered a Devils goal in under a minute, Nick Suzuki buried a power-play goal off a Lane Hutson feed to tie it again before intermission, and Jake Evans put Montreal ahead for good in the third. Final: Canadiens 3, Devils 2. Montreal improved to 13-5-4 after entering the night at 12-5-4, against a New Jersey team that came in at 15-6-0 on a two-game winning streak. That's a real result against a good team, and it should count for something.
But what's being treated as a breakthrough was, underneath the score, a team that kept handing a dangerous Devils lineup chances to take the game back. New Jersey scored twice and could have scored more. Montreal's defensive zone was a mess for long stretches, and the only reason that didn't matter is that Jacob Fowler settled down after a shaky start and stopped making it worse. Fowler bailing his team out of its own coverage breakdowns says more about his night than about the system underneath.
Then there's the power play, which had been so bad for so long that Montreal needed to snap an 0-for-14 drought just to tie this game. A unit that cold for that long, a quarter of the way into a season that's supposed to be building toward playoff hockey, is the real problem here. One power-play goal against a tired Devils penalty kill means it finally happened once, after fourteen misses before it.
Evans scored the goal that actually won the game. Fowler, thrown into a lineup already down Josh Anderson and Chris Kreider, did enough in net to survive his own defense. Brett Berard made his NHL debut in that same lineup, and the team found a way to win around him. That's a coaching staff and a locker room that competed hard for one night in November. Whether Martin St-Louis has built a team that can win four rounds in the spring is a separate question, and Wednesday didn't answer it.
Connor Hellebuyck took his first loss with New Jersey this season. Hellebuyck stopped a lot of pucks and lost anyway, because his team let a cold-shooting opponent hang around long enough to catch a break. That happens to good goalies in November, and it'll probably happen to Fowler soon too, given how much defensive-zone time Montreal conceded even in a game it won.
A real playoff identity comes from stopping the other team from generating chances. Montreal rode a hot goalie and a power play snapping out of a slump in the same 60 minutes instead. Montreal got away with it Wednesday without ever stopping New Jersey's chances, and getting away with it only postpones the problem. Fans who treat those as the same thing are setting themselves up for disappointment every spring.
The next road trip will tell more than this game did. Beating a good team once while getting outplayed for stretches is a nice two points. A playoff resume needs more than that, and Montreal's power play and defensive structure aren't there yet.




