Kyle Davidson owns this. Connor Bedard got hurt in the faceoff circle again on Tuesday night, and the general manager who has known for years that his captain had no business carrying this team's draws gets the blame, whatever the test results say.
Fifty-four seconds into the third period against Toronto, Bedard set up for a draw against Nick Paul. Paul's stick came down on his right hand, Bedard yelled out, dropped to the ice and went straight to the locker room. He didn't come back. He'd scored earlier in the night, and the Blackhawks went on to beat the Leafs 6-3 at the United Center. None of it mattered.
Jeff Blashill offered the postgame version of a shrug: "It looked what it looked like. I hate to comment further until I know more." Testing was scheduled for Wednesday, and there's still no official diagnosis.
The instant read on the broadcast was the right shoulder. Sports-medicine physician Dr. Brian Sutterer watched the same footage and pushed back: "I have never seen anybody dislocate their shoulder and hold their arm in this position." He thinks a hand or finger injury is more likely. Everybody in Chicago should be hoping he's right. It doesn't change who put Bedard in that spot.
The pattern
Last December, Bedard hurt his right shoulder on a faceoff against the Blues and missed 12 games. Over the summer he had surgery on his left shoulder after crashing into the boards in an offseason training drill, and that cost him the first six games of this season. Now a 21-year-old who's already had multiple shoulder problems goes down in the circle again, on the right side, on the same kind of play that sidelined him last season.
The best case for Davidson is bad luck. The left shoulder had nothing to do with faceoffs. If Sutterer is right, Tuesday was a stick on the hand, which can happen to any centre on any draw. And the Hawks are lousy at the dot no matter who takes the faceoff, so pulling Bedard wouldn't change much.
Every piece of that points straight back at the GM. If Chicago loses draws no matter who takes them, then Bedard's draws buy the team almost nothing, and the only thing left on the scale is the risk to the player this franchise is built around. Bedard keeps lining up because there's nobody better. As of late October, Chicago ranked last in the NHL in faceoff win percentage, and Bedard was the only true centre on the roster above 44 percent through ten games. Your best faceoff man is a kid with a shoulder history because you never found a real one. That's a roster problem, and the roster belongs to Davidson.
He knew
Davidson can't claim he didn't see it coming. Back in 2024 he publicly named faceoffs as the weak spot in Bedard's game, pointed out that a lot of the league's top faceoff men are veterans, and added, "It's something that I know he's put work into after practice." So the plan was extra reps after practice. Then a draw hurt Bedard's right shoulder in St. Louis, and surgery followed on the left one. By late October this season, Chicago was still the worst team in the league in the circle. Two years of knowing, and the fix never arrived.
Blashill gets a slice of this too. He decides who goes out for each draw, and he kept sending a player with Bedard's medical file into a stick fight with Nick Paul. A coach picks from the centres he's handed, though, and Davidson did the handing.
Davidson hasn't said a word publicly about this injury. The only reaction anyone got was the look on his face during the broadcast. A grimace from the box is cheap. Bedard shouldn't take another faceoff this season, and Davidson should spend every day before the trade deadline finding the centre who takes them instead. If he can't protect the player he built this whole thing around, Chicago should find a general manager who can.




