Gavin McKenna's bail-out along the wall on Thursday night was a bad hockey play, and the "he's 18, he's small, it's smart" defense falls apart the second you watch the replay. A skinny rookie is allowed to pull away from a hit. He is not allowed to leave the puck sitting there for the other team, and his own coach has already shown what he does to McKenna when he gives it away.
In Toronto's November 19 game against the Kings, a loose puck squirted along the boards and Samuel Helenius came in hard on the forecheck. McKenna pulled out of the battle rather than get pushed into the boards, and Los Angeles retrieved the puck uncontested. He didn't get it back. The clip spread fast, and fans were calling it cowardly and asking for a benching within hours.
The case for McKenna is real, and it's the one most people are making. He's 18. He's listed at 5-foot-11 and somewhere between 164 and 170 pounds, depending on whose roster page you trust. He was the No. 1 pick in the 2026 draft, and nobody in Toronto wants him folded into the glass over one puck in November. NHL Central Scouting even sold the trait as a strength before the draft: "He's not going to put himself in bad situations and he has the smarts to avoid them."
Sure. Smart avoidance looks like beating the forechecker to the puck, or turning your shoulder so the hit glances off while you keep possession. Small skilled players live on that skill. McKenna did neither. He peeled off and the Kings skated away with it. Calling that a clever survival instinct is generous to the point of being silly. It was a giveaway.
The flaw has a paper trail. Daily Faceoff's pre-draft profile said "he seemed afraid to engage physically along the boards a year ago," credited him with being much more physically engaged by the second half of his draft year, and added that "McKenna absolutely needs to bulk up if he's going to be able to dominate in the NHL." This one shift confirms the old habit never fully left, and every opposing video coach saw the same clip you did. Forecheckers will go looking for it now.
The Leafs can't afford to hand out free possessions. They were 8-13-2 entering Thursday's game, and McKenna, through his first 23 NHL games, had six goals, 14 points and a minus-9. The points are fine for a teenager. The minus-9 is the number that should bother everyone, and plays like this one are how a skill winger ends up there.
McKenna owns the shift. Jim Hiller owns what happens next. Earlier this season Hiller sat McKenna for turning the puck over and told reporters, "You just can't do it." In the same breath he called him "a great young player." Both things were true then and both are true now. Bailing out of a puck battle is a turnover with no stick involved, and if Hiller benches a teenager for a bad pass but shrugs at this, he's teaching him that the only mistakes that count are the pretty ones. That's backwards, and it's how a No. 1 pick learns to play on the perimeter for a decade.
He just needs to come out of the corner with the puck, or take the bump trying. Hiller should sit him for a shift and tell him exactly why. McKenna can survive a short benching. Toronto can't survive a franchise winger who gives up the wall every time someone bigger shows up.




