Leny Yoro deserved to go, and Matthijs de Ligt and Mauricio Pochettino deserve to carry it. The straight red in the eighth minute at Anfield was correct, and the sequence that forced it was built by a centre-back who hadn't played a Premier League game in almost a year and a manager who picked him anyway.
The law is simple
A hopeful long ball from inside Liverpool's own half went over the top, De Ligt was caught out, and Alexander Isak was in. Yoro came across late, too slow to cover, and brought Isak down as the last man right on the edge of the box. That's a clear goalscoring opportunity denied, and it's a red every time. A referee who keeps the card in his pocket there becomes the scandal himself.
The case for leniency rests on Isak's touch, the idea that the ball had run away from him and the chance was never really clear. Nothing about how the move actually played out backs that up. The ball was clean, it sent Isak through, and Yoro caught him right at the edge of the area with the play still live. You can want a sharper DOGSO test for strikers who lose control of the ball. This was the wrong incident to hang that argument on.
The card stands; now for the blame.
De Ligt opened the door
De Ligt was making his first Premier League appearance in 357 days after a back injury, recalled ahead of Harry Maguire for Pochettino's first match in charge. One ball over the top and he was gone. Yoro was left with two options, foul Isak or watch him run in on goal, and he took the only one a last defender takes. He was slow getting across, and that's on him, but he was only scrambling in the first place because the man beside him had already been beaten.
The bill came due at once. Dominik Szoboszlai put the free kick into the net, Florian Wirtz made it 2-0 in the 13th minute, and United were two down and a man short before the game had found its rhythm.
Pochettino picked it
Pochettino walked into a mess. He was appointed during the international break after Michael Carrick was sacked, and he inherited a side in the relegation zone and without a Premier League win in eight entering this game. A manager with one break to learn a squad has to gamble somewhere at the back.
He chose to gamble with the rustiest centre-back he had, at Anfield, against a Liverpool side sitting fourth going into the weekend. That was his decision and nobody else's, and it blew up inside eight minutes.
Yoro took the walk. The red belongs on De Ligt's afternoon and on Pochettino's team sheet, and the new manager's first job is admitting he got it wrong.




