Michigan was right to answer Sean Barnhill's hit. The brawl got as big as it did because Michigan State couldn't stay in its own penalty box, and the officiating crew at Yost couldn't make them.
Michigan led 5-1 midway through the third period on Friday night when Barnhill, a Michigan State sophomore defenseman, drove Nick Moldenhauer into the boards from behind, off the puck. The game was over. There was nothing left to win with that play. It was called boarding, and Barnhill finished the night with a boarding minor, a fighting major and a game disqualification. When an opponent does that to your teammate in garbage time, you go get him. That's the oldest rule in hockey, and Michigan followed it. Good.
The second wave
The officials broke up the first fight and sent players to the box. Then the whole thing started again near the Michigan bench. Barnhill, Shane Vansaghi and Matt Lahey left the penalty box to get back into it. Michigan State captain Patrick Geary skated into the Michigan bench area alone, got pinned against the boards, and drew a game misconduct. He's the player who's supposed to be pulling teammates out of a pile. Instead he went looking for one.
That restart is on Michigan State and on the officials. Once a fight gets broken up and players are sent to the box, it's over. Three Spartans decided otherwise, and nobody stopped them. Once players can walk out of the box whenever they feel like it, nobody's running that box. The crew handed out plenty afterward: six disqualifications, three per team, with fighting majors that carry a minimum one-game suspension. The suspensions came after the damage was already done. Their job was keeping a separated fight separated, and they failed at it.
Michigan's ugly minute
Michigan doesn't skate away clean either. Adam Valentini and Aidan Park came off the Michigan bench to join in, and Jack Nesbitt punched Geary while Geary was lying on the ice. That punch is indefensible. Geary made a dumb choice skating into that bench alone, and hitting a man who's down is cowardly regardless. The Big Ten or NCAA could still add discipline, and if they do, Nesbitt belongs on the list. But Michigan didn't throw the hit from behind, and Michigan wasn't the team whose players left the box to restart a fight the officials had already ended.
Staged? Look at the bill
This wasn't staged. Look at what it cost Michigan. Michael Hage, a Canadiens prospect who entered Friday as the nation's leading scorer, was disqualified along with Drew Schock and Nic Sima, and all three were suspended for Saturday's rematch at Munn Ice Arena in East Lansing. Nobody fakes a brawl that costs the country's top scorer the next night's game against his biggest rival. Barnhill, Vansaghi and Lahey drew the same suspension. Six ejections is the most in this rivalry since 1991.
The hit from behind reflects poorly on the sport. Protecting a teammate afterward doesn't. That's exactly what players should do. The real problem came later: a box that wouldn't stay shut.
Michigan State beat Michigan 5-2 in the previous meeting, back in February. On Friday, Michigan, ranked No. 1 entering the game, ran the Spartans off the ice, and Michigan State answered the scoreboard with a cheap shot and a jailbreak. Michigan's response was justified. Michigan State caused this twice, and the officiating crew failed to stop it.




