Jim Hiller should be fired, and John Chayka should do it this week. Thursday's shootout loss to Los Angeles made it eight straight defeats for Toronto, and the decisions that mattered most at the end of it belonged to the coach and nobody else.
Start with the morning. Hours before puck drop, Hiller finally made the change he'd been hammered for refusing to make. Gavin McKenna, the No. 1 draft pick, skated on the second line with John Tavares and Nick Paul and was bumped up to the top power-play unit. William Nylander, who had gone five straight games without a point, dropped to the third line. That's a coach admitting, in public, that the old lineup was wrong and his most talented young forward deserved a bigger role.
Then the game reached the moments a coach actually gets paid for, and the bigger role vanished. Overtime produced Auston Matthews ringing one off the crossbar and Darren Raddysh getting stopped on a breakaway. When it went to a shootout, Hiller sent out Matthews, Nylander and Jack Roslovic. Darcy Kuemper stopped all three, Adrian Kempe scored, and McKenna, the player promoted that very morning, never got a turn.
Nylander is the part I can't get past. Hiller judged him cold enough to demote at breakfast and trusted him enough to hand him a shootout attempt by night. A coach can hold either opinion of a player. Holding both in one day means he doesn't actually have one, and a team on an 0-7-1 run can't afford a coach who decides things by mood.
There's no clear standard behind what happened Thursday. The rookie earned a spot on the top six and the top power play that morning, then sat through every shootout attempt that night, in a game his team was about to lose.
The collapse that got them there belongs on the coach's desk too. Dakota Joshua's goal at 2:34 of the second period made it 3-0. The Kings then scored three straight in under 12 minutes. A three-goal lead at home, with the second period barely started, is the easiest kind of game to manage, and Toronto's bench managed it straight into a shootout.
The best case for keeping Hiller is that the Kings aren't much good either, sitting 7-11-2 even after this win, and that a team losing eight straight has problems no coach created. Some of that's true, and it makes Thursday worse. Toronto has talent: Matthews scored the 68th game-opening goal of his career that night, passing Mats Sundin for the most in franchise history. Blowing a three-goal lead to a struggling team is what happens when a coach can't steady his room. A thin roster doesn't fill out a shootout list. Hiller did.
Chayka is the one who hired him. He fired Craig Berube on May 13, citing the need for an "organizational shift," then hired Hiller on June 17, the same coach the Kings had fired on March 1 after three seasons. On Thursday, Los Angeles walked into Scotiabank Arena and beat the coach it had already let go.
On Monday, with the skid at six, Chayka called the results "unacceptable" and backed Hiller anyway. "We got a lot of confidence in Jim, and Mats (Sundin) and I have full support behind him," he said. "I think it's on us as a group to work through this." Toronto has lost twice since. Spreading the blame across "us as a group" is how a general manager protects a hire he made, and the group has gone 0-2 on his confidence.
The Leafs sit at 8-13-3. Fire Hiller now, because every game Chayka waits from here goes on Chayka's record.




