Chris Getz won this trade, and all the sympathy pouring in for Luis Castillo and Davis Martin as they pack for Coors Field has no bearing on that. The White Sox handed Colorado a contract that was coming apart in real time, and the Rockies agreed to pay all of it.
Look at what Chicago was holding. Castillo started 2026 in Seattle with a 5.06 ERA, allowing 107 hits in 99.2 innings, and arrived on the South Side ahead of the deadline. Then he got worse: an 8.42 ERA across nine appearances for the White Sox before a right shoulder impingement landed him on the injured list. He's owed $22.75 million for 2027.
On Thursday night, Getz sent Castillo and Martin to the Rockies for left-hander Sean Sullivan and catching prospect Douglas Veliz. Colorado is absorbing Castillo's full salary, which saves Chicago roughly $24 million.
Getz cleaned up his own mess
The Castillo deadline deal was Getz's mistake. He brought in a three-time All-Star to help a team that went on to make its first postseason since 2021, and Castillo was a disaster in Chicago. Plenty of executives would have kept him on the roster another year, called it rotation depth, and hoped for the best. Getz found a taker within a few months. Castillo's contract has now changed hands twice in roughly four months, which means two front offices have looked at it and decided someone else should pay it.
Admitting a bad bet by actually getting rid of it is harder than it sounds, and most GMs don't have the stomach for it.
Martin was the price, and Getz sold at the right time
The cost is real. Martin made 28 starts in 2026 and went 9-8 with a 3.95 ERA. For a stretch of the spring he was one of the better pitchers in the American League, and he's still pre-arbitration, so he's cheap. The White Sox didn't want to give him up, and Colorado treated him as the prize of the deal. Getz did not get this salary relief for free.
But look at how Martin's year actually went. His ERA climbed from 3.41 in the first half to 5.12 in the second. A calf issue slowed him late, and by October he'd been pushed to mop-up work, making one relief appearance in the postseason. FanGraphs' Depth Charts projection has him at a 4.47 FIP for 2027, up from his 3.83 this year. He did close the regular season with a 1.71 ERA over his final five games, and that hot finish is why he could carry a contract out the door. You sell a pitcher when another team values him more than the trend line says you should, and Colorado did.
The Coors sympathy is misplaced
Both pitchers are headed to Coors Field, where pitchers have struggled for years. If you feel bad for Castillo, who's now been shipped out twice and will call altitude home, that's a decent human reaction. It has nothing to do with grading the White Sox. Front offices get judged on run prevention and payroll room. Getz pulled an 8.42 ERA out of his rotation and roughly $24 million off his books in one phone call. If Martin gets hammered in Denver, that's the bet Colorado chose to make.
Savings only matter if you spend them. Chicago hasn't turned that money into anything yet, and every pitcher linked to the White Sox this winter is speculation. The club introduced Dustin May hours before this trade. If the money just sits there, this becomes a payroll cut with a useful young starter thrown in, and Getz and ownership will deserve every bit of the criticism.
That's worth watching, but it doesn't change what happened here. On Wednesday the White Sox were stuck with Castillo's 2027 salary. Now they have the room and the prospects, and the Rockies have the risk.
Getz bought a broken contract at the deadline and unloaded it in November with a decent pitcher as the sweetener. That's a GM fixing his own blunder before it cost him another season, and anyone docking him for where the pitchers landed is grading the wrong team.




