K'Andre Miller's cross-check on Connor McDavid on Saturday was soft, and anyone calling it violent is selling you a clip. The cross-checks that deserved the outrage came a month ago, from the same Carolina defenseman on the same Oilers captain, and the referees let them go without a whistle.
Start with Edmonton's own people. The Oilers' team site called Miller's first-period penalty "debatable." Oilers beat coverage was harsher, calling it "a weak call that had no business being a penalty." Those are the voices with every reason to scream about a shot on their captain, and they shrugged. If the hometown side won't call it violent, you shouldn't either.
Then look at what McDavid did with the power play Miller handed him. He threaded a cross-ice pass to Leon Draisaitl for a one-timer, and Edmonton scored, with Evan Bouchard picking up the other assist. Later he set up Vasily Podkolzin's power-play goal that tied the game 4-4. A guy who'd just been hurt doesn't spend the rest of the night running the power play. By every sign that game gave, he was fine.
The whistle that should make you angry
About a month earlier, Edmonton beat Carolina 6-5, and McDavid "took a nasty crosscheck or two from K'Andre Miller," as one game review put it, with no penalty called. Same defenseman, same star, and nastier contact by the description at the time. No whistle.
So the officials ignored the rough version and blew the whistle on the debatable one. That's backwards, and it belongs to the NHL. A cross-check standard that flips from one meeting to the next between the same two players is a coin toss, and every defenseman in the league can see it. Miller learned in the first game that leaning on McDavid with his stick costs nothing. The second game told him it might cost two minutes, depending on who's wearing the armband that night. Nobody can play to that rule, and nobody should have to.
Miller doesn't get off clean. He also went to the box for boarding and for roughing McDavid, three penalties in one game, with at least two of them on McDavid. That's sloppy, careless hockey from a 6-foot-5 defenseman who won a Stanley Cup with Carolina and should know better than to keep giving the best player in the world free power plays. Sloppy earns a seat in the box, and that's all it earns. Calling every cross-check on McDavid violent cheapens the word for the night someone actually gets hurt.
Oilers fans hunting for a grievance from Saturday have a better one sitting right there. Edmonton led 3-1 and lost 7-4, with Carolina's power play scoring again and again in the second and third periods. The weak call on Miller gave Edmonton a goal. Their own trips to the box gave the game away.
Miller should clean up his stick. The referees owe everyone an explanation for how his "nasty" cross-checks on McDavid were fine a month ago and a debatable one was a penalty on Saturday. Until they give one, point the outrage at the officials. They're the ones who earned it.




