The nine-year, nearly $400 million Mets offer for Tarik Skubal is a sales pitch, and you should read it like one. One man posted it, none of the reporters tracking the talks have matched it, and the outlets that turned it into a headline within hours did somebody else's negotiating for free.
Here's everything that's actually out there. Jim Duquette, a former Mets GM, wrote on X that "There has been a constant buzz since Vegas and multiple MLB sources have since confirmed that the initial Mets offer on Tarik Skubal was 9 years almost $400 million." Unnamed sources and buzz, nothing more concrete than that. Then the repost machine went to work, and every version of the story you saw traces back to that one post.
Now look at who hasn't said it. Jon Heyman, as of Monday, said the Mets' meeting with Skubal went well and that it remained unclear whether New York had even made an offer. Jeff Passan reported the Mets came away "impressed." Jim Bowden put the expected contract anywhere from $350 million to $500 million, a range wide enough to drive a team bus through. Nobody on that list has put their name next to nine years and $400 million. These are the people who live on this stuff. A record pitching deal doesn't stay off their feeds by accident.
Then there's the word "initial." It's the most useful word in the whole post, and it's useful to the seller. Telling the market a first offer was near $400 million tells every rival front office where the floor sits before they've written down a number of their own. Look at the calendar: the Mets met with Skubal on Monday, the Dodgers and Blue Jays on Tuesday, the Padres on Wednesday, and Heyman has two unnamed mystery teams in the mix. Buster Olney has reported that some involved expect the bidding to come down to the Mets and Blue Jays. A near-record figure going public that week squeezes Toronto, Los Angeles and San Diego harder than it tells the rest of us anything real.
And near-record it is. Almost $400 million over nine years works out to roughly $44.4 million a year, past the $43.33 million average held by Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander. I don't know who handed Duquette that number. Neither does anyone who reposted it, and that's the problem.
Maybe this is just what Skubal costs. He's a two-time AL Cy Young winner (2024 and 2025), he won the Triple Crown in 2024, and he turned 30 on November 20, the day the post went up. Pay for the front half of the deal, shrug at the back end, and $400 million looks like a sane bet for a pitcher like that. That's true, and it's exactly why the number works so well as leverage. A believable figure is the only kind worth leaking, and a two-time Cy Young winner makes $400 million believable to anyone who hears it.
None of this means the Mets are bluffing about wanting him. Heyman has called them "probably the favorite," ahead of the Dodgers, the team Skubal was traded to in 2026. Ken Rosenthal isn't sold on New York as the fit, saying "I'm not sure, and it remains to be seen." Skubal remains unsigned, with a deal expected before the December 1 lockout deadline, so this could all look different by tomorrow.
If Heyman or Passan matches the figure, I'll eat it. Until then, nine years and $400 million is an asking price somebody wanted every other front office to read, and the outlets that ran it as fact just did the spreading for free.




