The White Sox just handed Dustin May three years and $52.5 million. It's a bad bet. This is a team that spent years stripping payroll to the studs, suddenly sprinting to the front of the line for a pitcher whose single most reliable feature is that he gets hurt.
Start with what Chicago actually bought. May has two Tommy John surgeries on his resume, in 2021 and 2023, and he missed essentially all of 2024 recovering from surgery to repair a torn esophagus. When he has pitched lately, he's been fine and nothing more. Over his last two seasons combined he went 14-20. In 2026, split between the Cardinals and Brewers, he put up a 4.70 ERA and a 1.32 WHIP across 145.2 innings. In 2025, between the Dodgers and Red Sox, it was a 4.96 ERA over 132.1 innings. Seven big-league seasons in, his career ERA sits at 4.12 and his career WAR is 2.8. That's a back-end starter who has rarely been available.
Now look at what everyone else thought he was worth. MLB Trade Rumors projected two years and $30 million with an opt-out. ESPN's Kiley McDaniel had him at a single year for $14 million. Spotrac, the most generous of the bunch, landed at three years and $46.25 million. The White Sox beat even that outlier by roughly six million dollars and tacked on term. When a rebuilding club clears the highest estimate on the board for a 30-ish arm with this medical file, that's talking yourself into a dream.
There's a case for May. The stuff is genuinely nasty, he was reportedly the most sought-after free-agent starter at the GM Meetings behind only Tarik Skubal, and a club finally willing to spend beats a club that refuses to. If the mechanics click and the body holds, three years at $17.5 million looks shrewd in hindsight. That kind of money gets paid for a track record. His track record is two years of league-average results wrapped around a decade of injuries.
The ring doesn't change that. May was a role player on Milwaukee's World Series roster, and in the postseason he worked 11 innings with a 5.73 ERA. Chicago is buying name recognition at a premium.
This one belongs to the front office. Chris Getz and the people approving the checks under Jerry Reinsdorf decided to make May their first real splash, and they overshot the entire industry to do it. There are worse things a rebuild can do than spend. Spending this much, on this profile, above what anyone else valued him at, is one of them.




